Skip to main content

Judicial Federalism in Australia

History, Theory, Doctrine and Practice


, , ,





Publication date


Page extent


AUD $160.00 gst included

SKU: 9781760022679 Category:

The Australian High Court has implied from Chapter III of the Constitution significant protections for judicial independence and fair trial processes. In the last 25 years, these protections have been extended to the judiciaries of the Australian States with often-overlooked consequences for the operation of the Australian federation. Chapter III protections perform an important role in safeguarding individual liberties in a system largely bereft of constitutional rights protections. But they have also frustrated, or mandated substantial amendment to, a number of legislative initiatives.

Unsurprisingly then, Chapter III is the site of significant constitutional disagreement. Australia’s second century has heralded heightened tension between governments and the courts over the proper scope of the limitations derived from Chapter III. These limits are some of the most dynamic in Australian constitutional law.

To inform and illuminate these ongoing debates, Judicial Federalism in Australia: History, Theory, Doctrine and Practice provides a holistic analysis of the federal influence of Chapter III. It considers the historical underpinnings of the Chapter, tracing its development from the colonial justice system through the convention debates and into the first years of Federation. It then provides an overview of the theoretical and doctrinal development of Australia’s Chapter III jurisprudence as it relates to the States and Territories and how it has affected the operation of the federation. Finally, the book provides, for the first time, an empirical study of the effect of the Court’s Chapter III jurisprudence on the development of State and Territory policies, focusing on anti-organised crime initiatives, the introduction of administrative super tribunals and specialist courts such as drug courts and Indigenous sentencing courts.

About the Authors
Table of Cases
Table of Statutes

Ch 1 – Introduction

Part 1
Ch 2 – The Evolution of the Colonial Judiciary
Ch 3 – The Conventions
Ch 4 – The Judicial Landscape Prior to the Decision in Kable

Part 2
Ch 5 – State Parliaments and Chapter III: The Constitutional Moment of Choice in Kable
Ch 6 – Kable and “it’s Sequelae”: Kable’s Application to State Law and Order

Part 3
Ch 7 – State Law and Order Policy and Constitutional Uncertainty
Ch 8 – Kable, Federalism and Rights
Ch 9 – State Tribunals and Judicial Federalism
Ch 10 – Conclusion

Judicial federalism is the label that has been applied to the cluster of ideas and power relations at the intersection of federalism and judicial power in Australian constitutional law. Here, for the first time, this topic receives comprehensive treatment in book form.

Julian R Murphy, Law Institute Journal, Law Institute of Victoria, January 2022

The practically contingent nature of constitutional law means that it is important to understand not only the cases themselves, but also the history, theory, doctrine and practice that sits underneath a constitutional position such as judicial federalism. This wide-ranging book is a fine compilation, and a sophisticated synthesis, of those diverse resources and insights, which will be of considerable assistance in understanding the future development of the law in this field.

Brendan Lim, Bar News 105, Summer 2021

You may also like…